[This is (maybe) an ongoing series looking at older and newer gigs by my band The Wolf Tones, which places a strong emphasis on improvisation and does not pick a setlist in advance... so why did we play these songs this time? Let us explore...]
This December 2025 show has a lot going for it. It's nearly 2-1/2 hours, for one thing. But moreso, it's a really good mix of what The Wolf Tones are. This set's got traditional bluegrass, country, reggae, a grassed-up metal cover, and a song from the obscure holiday children's book/Christmas special "The Snowman."
Oh yeah, and Joe Kolenda thought this particular Tuesday was the annual "Jaws"-themed holiday party, and came dressed as Woods Hole Oceanographic Institute biologist Dr. Matt Hooper.
It was a little over a week before Christmas, everyone was in a really good mood, and it shows. Let's hop into the first set:
Mend This Heart of Mine, Thanks a Lot, Tangled Up in Blue > Columbus Stockade Blues, Stealing the Jewels*, Chase the Devil, My Gal**, Luckiest Man 'Twas Born**, Rainbow in the Dark > 54-46 Was My Number, Jimmy Olsen's Blues > Tangled Up in Blue > Hobo Song
*Original
**feat. Dr. Matt Hooper, harmonica
This features one of my favorite goofy (and sometimes accidental) set tricks. We played the first half of Dylan's "Tangled Up in Blue," and then took it into another song, ending without segueing back into "Tangled." And then later on, in the middle of a jam, we did the back half.
This time we did it on purpose, and it's mainly fun because people who really like "Tangled Up in Blue" are gonna wonder whether or not we'll come back to it, and it's a nice little surprise/gift when we do.
...that doesn't always happen.
There's been more than a couple versions of "Raleigh & Spencer" where we railed off into three or four other songs and either forgot or never found a good place to circle back. But there's just as many more where we do, so it sorta becomes this fun mystery for the audience.
This show was also the debut of my favorite Max Romeo reggae tune, "Chase the Devil," which I then didn't play again for a full ten months.
We medley'd up a couple of repertoire regulars, Dio's "Rainbow in the Dark" and Toots & the Maytals' "54-46 Was My Number." The Toots number, despite only having two chords, is another one of those jumping-off points that always tends to develop into a long jam and then develop into something else. As I'm writing this, however, I'm glancing at the setlist and noticed that, contrary to what I JUST F***ING SAID, we ended this version without taking it elsewhere.
Whatever. Then we did "Hobo Song." On to the late set:
If You're Ever In Oklahoma, I'm Gonna Sleep with One Eye Open, Ooh Las Vegas > Jam > That's It*, Tupelo Honey > All Aboard > Walking in the Air > All Aboard > House by the Sea > Pound On Me*, Breathe > Colt 45, Werewolves of London
*Original
Again, we ease in with a little bit of traditional 'grass and a bouncy fun take on Gram Parsons' "Ooh Las Vegas," then we start getting a little weird with our funky tune, "That's It."
A lot of times, Nemo's bass solo would determine where the next song was coming from. I'd listen to what he was doing and look for something that felt like the direction he was headed. You don't wanna do it too early, because you never know where a good jam might develop and go. But as I heard him gettin' a little stankier, "That's It" was an easy pick.
The mid-set jam is where it's at, though. It's impossible to do too many Van Morrison covers. I used to do "Tupelo Honey" a lot at solo gigs back in the day, and Nemo (as always!) had a great take on it. Then he cranked it back up with Del McCoury's "All Aboard." This is the type of tune that has just enough chord changes to probably require a rehearsal, or at least a couple run-throughs backstage.
We had tried it once before earlier in the year, and it's on the official Archive setlist as "All Aboard > All Abort."
In the middle of it, I got to sneak in a childhood memory. I had "The Snowman" book and the accompanying LP when I was a kid. It's basically the Frosty the Snowman story, but told in a very loving way that will make you cry, both as a kid and adult. "Walking in the Air" might actually be the only part of the whole record with lyrics, from a scene when the snowman and the boy are flying over the winter landscape. It's pretty and haunting and seemed to fit really well into that particular moment.
We rounded out "All Aboard," did a relatively quick "House by the Sea" and finished the jam with Nemo's tune, "Pound On Me."
The remainder of the set is some fairly-standard late-set stuff for this time period. It's interesting, though, how we've developed a whole stable of tunes that primarily revolve around E-minor and A/A7/A-minor, which kind of all orbit one another when late-set jams wander into that particular musical territory.
If we're coming out of a song and the jam is edging toward E-minor, just off the top of my head, we could dive into an Iron & Wine song, a Bob Marley song, a Pink Floyd song, an original tune, and two different Dr. John songs.
Oh! And during "Werewolves," not only did I do the Dave Matthews "Sweet Home Alabama/Southern Man" mash-up, I also sang the Neil Young diss verse from "Alabama" beforehand!
We're wolves. We play bluegrass. It gets weird. It's right there on the front page of the website.






